sunshine-oats - Nice result, Anna! How would you feel about getting those cookies out of the house, as you did with the almond butter? Regarding Omega 3 fatty acids, unless you are carefully weighing, measuring, and inputting everything you eat in a given day (which is NOT recommended, of course) that reading in CRONometer is unlikely to be very accurate.
JeffN wrote:While flax and walnuts may be a rich source of omega 3's, and some will recommended a certain amount, they are not really required at all as all plants have omega 3's and you are getting in plenty even if you don't consume any flax of walnuts.
That said, if you are concerned about this, adding some leafy greens to your menu is one way to include even more Omega 3s, while remaining adherent to MWL. For preloading, ideally the soup should be loaded with non-starchy vegetables, either chunky or blended is fine (
In this study, differing textures of soup had comparable effects in reducing total meal energy intake).
sunshine-oats wrote:on the one hand the program says it is ok to graze.. on the other hand it says it is ok to be hungry.. which one is it and if snacks are ok and not to be eliminated.. should they follow the 50/50 plate method?
I'm glad you raised this question; I think people tend to get a bit confused about the MWL Refinement labelled It's
OK to Be Hungry. When we review the specific description, it becomes much more clear what Dr. McDougall means by this.
It's OK to be Hungry:
Sometimes you will find yourself in a situation where there is no healthy food available – like when you are out shopping, at a party, or dining with friends. You don't have to eat. No harm will be done. You won't starve to death by waiting a few hours until something healthy is available. Delaying gratification is the smart thing to do and when you do finally eat the right foods they will taste extra delicious.
Program Protocol: No one went hungry during the 10 days with us. One of the lessons of our program was successfully taught – "You can eat as much as you want of delicious foods and lose weight."
So, Dr. McDougall is not talking about refraining from eating the recommended foods whenever we feel hungry; rather, he is making the point that we can choose to delay eating until the recommended foods are available, instead of eating calorie rich or otherwise troublesome foods. Snacks are completely acceptable, and applying the 50/50 ratio to snacks will help support sustainable progress.
JeffN wrote:slugmom wrote:So ... if optimizing weight loss is my goal ... and I'm legitimately hungry, or really munchy and want a snack ... which would be better? Popcorn? Fruit?
IMH(P&P)O, and based on calorie density, of the two, I would say fruit. However, vegetables would be a better choice and/or a meal of 50% starch and 50% vegetables (and/or fruit) by volume. A meal of 50% starch and 50% vegetables by volume would have a very low calorie density. So, a bowl of 50% oatmeal and 50% berries by volume or a bowl of 50% rice and 50% veggies by volume may be the better choice. You get the starch to help satisfy you and the fruit and/or veggies to help lower the calorie density.
Try not to be overly concerned with perfectly distinguishing and recognizing hunger signals. Remember,
JeffN wrote:You don’t have to figure it out or work out it. Only follow the guidelines. When hungry (regardless of whether you may think it is true hunger, appetite, or something else) just eat. Eat of the recommended foods as outlined in the 10 point checklist.
Over time, it will work itself out.
PonysPlants - Congratulations on hitting that 50 pound milestone, Naomi! What an excellent birthday gift to give yourself! I can imagine how much you miss walking outside; I've still been going for a walk at least once each day, and I'm dreading the inevitable day when the weather makes that an unpleasant experience. Carry on your admirable efforts!
jan_npr - Down 1.3 lbs! Are there any strategies you are interested in trying for eliminating the calorie dense foods and higher fat plant foods? Is it feasible to remove those items from your immediate environment, or at least make them much more difficult to access? Could you demonstrate for your daughter how easy it is to cook without oil? Keep in mind,
JeffN wrote:Nutrients and the RDA/DRI
The RDA/DRI’s do not always apply to those following a healthy starch based diet. However by following the guidelines, especially starting meals with a soup or salad and the 50/50 guideline, ones diet with be very nutrient dense. In regard to weight, we do not recommend tracking your nutrients. Follow the plan, and the nutrients will be there.
CindyD - Congratulations on that 22.5 BMI! I'm glad to hear you don't find this weigh-in worrisome; continued attention to the MWL 10-Point Checklist is the appropriate response. How fun to be able to put a DVD in the hands of anyone who asks you about this way of eating!
Rebecka22 - Hooray for your perfect week! I'm glad those eliminations, substitutions, adjustments and alternatives are working out for you. Jeff's discussion of chocolate/cocoa/cacao is
here.
JeffN wrote:Cocoa is ~50%, ~30% saturated fat and ~1000 cal/lb. Most cocoa powders, including organic ones, are contaminated with heavy metals.
You can read more about it
here, including my recommendations/allowances.
Keep up your diligent efforts; 10/10 feeling easy comes with time, experience and loads of trial, error and adjustment.
wstokes - I'm sorry those big emotions made this week feel tough for you! I agree that it is important that indiscretions and exceptions don't become the norm,
lest we end up with an "exceptional" diet. I want to remind everyone that fasting is not recommended for MWL; it violates the fundamental basic principle of the MWL Program: "whenever hungry, eat until comfortably full of the recommended foods." Jeff discusses this in detail
here.
Rita<3 - WOW! Big result! That looks like an outstanding week; well done getting rid of the crackers. I can imagine the difficulty inherent in your battles with chronic pain; just keep doing the best you can, treat yourself with compassion, and be careful not to overdo it. Keep getting the food right, and you'll keep seeing progress.
birdy birdy - Hang in there! That certainly does sound like a very taxing week! Now that the situation is resolved, put last week in the past, and focus your efforts on getting right back to the recommended pattern of behavior.
brookelikesrunning - 2 pounds is a dramatic result! I'm so sorry to hear you've been ill; I can imagine the COVID-19 diagnosis felt pretty scary. Glad you are asymptomatic and recovering. Do the best you can to move the 25%, 50%s and 75%s toward 100%.
squealcat - Impressive work thinking through the factors that contributed to the challenges you were facing, Marilyn, and taking steps to eliminate or resolve those factors! I totally agree that it is important to eat adherent meals that we really enjoy; personally, I almost exclusively eat my favorite foods. Enjoy your soup, japanese sweet potatoes (YUM!) and lentils!
GreenFroG - Excellent adherence! Bringing some further attention to the 50/50 ratio for meals and snacks seems like an appropriate step. Those last few pounds tend to be tenacious, for all the reasons Jeff discusses in
Why We Hit Plateaus and What We Can Do About Them.
jkcook - 2 more pounds gone! Seems like a pretty solid week! How would you feel about opting for veggie sushi for your next celebratory occasion? Onward!
HoustonJason - 3 pounds is a great result! Definitely seems like a pretty good week.
That recognition that you are at the beginning of a new, different, healthier lifestyle feels significant. Feeling good about both your choices and the results you are seeing is important. Keep at it!
Hope410 - 8/10 is still a respectable report! Well done bringing yourself back on track. Was anything different about the days when you decided to include bread and popcorn? Any changes to your environment, preparation or routine? Something I find helpful for overcoming resistance and building a habit is to "anchor" the desired behavior to something I do already, or a specific "slot" in my day; e.g. I exercise each morning after having some water and checking my email, I go for a postprandial walk after lunch, &c. Do you think something like that might work for you?