Moderators: JeffN, f1jim, John McDougall, carolve, Heather McDougall
Melinda wrote:I've been meditating for over 2 years. I have missed for a couple of periods and noticed the difference. It has made positive changes in my life.
Thrasymachus wrote:@hazelrah:
I was duped by Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche and his books, which are not even written by him. His Engrish is way too bad to even co-write ever a book in English. Listen to the guy on Youtube. If you go to his "co-authors" personal page he says he is the ghost writer for Yongey. Which is something that is easy to believe. That is actually what many-most Tibetan buddhist authors do. They have Westerners ghost write for them, Sogyal Rinpoche and the Dalai Lama do it too.
Second, they lie alot about Tibetan & buddhist history and make ridiculous claims for meditation like it is a panacea for suffering and that it should be the main pursuit of life. First, in Tibetan and other societies religion was mostly about buying or consuming karma, blessings and ceremony from the monks. Meditation had an actually small role in Buddhist history and almost no East Asian, Thai, Tibetan, meditates much or ever meditatied much. What they say is like saying to ignorant people that you can just train enough using my exclusive method to play like Lebron James. Some people have amazing mental fortitude and ability to endure, pain, suffering and cope. Just like you can increase your vertical jump and basketball skills especially if you are untrained, you can increase your calm and ability to cope to an extent with moderate meditation. But it has limits, just like there are limits for most of us in everything. We cannot become Lebron James no matter how hard we train.
Eric Swanson wrote:Eric Swanson Homepage: Tibetan Buddhism
...
Written with a humility that makes his words resonate and helped by the skillful writing of Eric Swanson (co-author/ghost writer of The Joy of Living) who has a way with words that makes the pages go down easy.
Thrasymachus wrote:@elbow:
Did you even read anything I wrote in this thread? This from the homepage of his alleged co-writer:mEric Swanson wrote:Eric Swanson Homepage: Tibetan Buddhism
...
Written with a humility that makes his words resonate and helped by the skillful writing of Eric Swanson (co-author/ghost writer of The Joy of Living) who has a way with words that makes the pages go down easy.
If you listen to Yongey's Youtube talks he speaks a rudimentary pidgin English, which belies his claims of talking to leading scientists since childhood. If that were true past his 30's as he is now, he should have had greater mastery. I know I cannot have scientific conversations in Greek, despite speaking it amongst my family since birth. Further you encounter none of the pop psychology or science in his books, in his speeches and talks. A ghostwriter is someone who writes books that are officially credited to another person. That kernel of honesty by Swanson explains it all.
Authentic Tibetan buddhism is dense useless nonsense like "The Supreme Source: The Fundamental Tantra Of Dzogchen Semde Kunjed Gyalpo" translated by Namkhai Norbu. The populist stuff like Yongey's works is largely the product of Westerners who appear deceptively as co-authors, and is more cheap pop psychology than authentic, and arcane buddhism. The publishing industry has a long tradition of ghostwriting. Most books by celebrities and popular musicians are more the product of the ghostwriter given mere credits as a co-author than the person credited as writing the book. Honesty on such subjects just sells alot less.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 19 guests